What did Robert Hur say about Beau Biden?


WASHINGTON – One of the most explosive claims in special counsel Robert Hur’s investigative report on President Joe Biden’s handling of classified documents portrayed the 81-year-old president as an elderly man with a memory so poor that he couldn’t remember when his own son died.
But the transcript of Hur’s interview with Biden shows the exchange about Beau Biden’s death was far from the senior moment that Hur made it out to be.
At the same time, the transcript contradicts Biden’s angry assertion that Hur raised the topic of Beau Biden’s death during their interview.
It was Biden, not Hur, who first mentioned Beau Biden’s death, according to the transcript.
The transcript, released Tuesday ahead of Hur’s testimony before the House Judiciary Committee, shows that the conversation between the president and the special prosecutor that transpired over two days last October was far more nuanced than either side has suggested.
What did Hur report say about Biden?
In his investigative report released last month, Hur concluded that Biden was careless in his handling of classified documents scattered across his Delaware residence.
But federal investigators declined to pursue criminal charges against Biden in part, they said, because of his “poor memory.”Prep for the polls: See who is running for president and compare where they stand on key issues in our Voter GuideBiden’s memory “was significantly limited,” Hur concluded, which he said would make it hard to get a jury to convict him.
At another point, Hur described the president as a “well-meaning elderly man with a poor memory.”Biden could not remember important details of his own life, Hur’s report said.
“He did not remember, even within several years, when his son Beau died,” the report says.
Visual guideHow does the Biden classified documents report compare to Trump’s?
What did Joe Biden actually say about Beau Biden?
The transcript of Hur’s interview with Biden on Oct. 8, 2023, however, shows a meandering conversation that eventually led to the topic of Beau Biden, who died of brain cancer in 2015.
Biden, who at times appeared to be thinking out loud, asked at one point what month Beau Biden died, but then went on to talk in detail about his close relationship with Beau and his other son, Hunter.
The exchange began when Hur asked where Biden kept papers related to his work at the University of Pennsylvania’s Biden Center, the University of Delaware’s Biden Institute, and the Cancer Moonshot program after leaving the vice presidency.
“This is, what, 2017, 2018, that area?” Biden asked.
“Yes, sir,” Hur responded.
Biden: “Remember, in this timeframe, my son is either been deployed or is dying.
… Even though I’m at Penn, I hadn’t walked away from the idea that I may run for office again.
But if I ran again, I ‘d be running for president.
And, and so what was happening, though – what month did Beau die?
Oh, God, May 30th.”Rachel Cotton, White House lawyer: “2015.”Unidentified male speaker: “2015.”Biden: “Was it 2015 he had died?”Unidentified male speaker: “It was May of 2015.”Biden: “It was 2015.”Robert Bauer, Biden’s personal lawyer: “Or I’m not sure the month, sir, but I think that was the year.”Marc Krickbaum, Hur’s deputy: “That’s right, Mr. President.
It –“Biden: “And what’s happened in the meantime is that as – and Trump gets elected in November of 2017?”Unidentified male speaker: “2016.”Unidentified male speaker: “’16.”Biden: “’16, 2016.
So – why do I have 2017 in here?”Ed Siskel, White House counsel: “That’s when you left office, January of 2017.”Biden: “Yeah, okay.
But that’s when Trump gets sworn in then, January –“Siskel: “Right.”Biden went on to speak in detail about his close relationship with his sons, his decision to write a book and how a white nationalist rally in Charlottesville, Va., prompted him to run for president in 2020.
Biden: “And in 2017, Beau had passed and – this is personal – the genesis of the book and the title ‘Promise Me, Dad’ was a – I know you’re all close with your sons and daughters, but Beau was like my right arm and Hunt was my left.
These guys were a year and a day apart and they could finish each other’ s sentences.
… Everybody knew how close we were.
There was not anybody in the world who wondered whether or not – anyway.”At one point in the conversation, Hur suggested it would be a good time for Biden to take a break.
“No, I,” Biden said, “let me just keep going to get it done.”A rematch:Trump shows slight lead over Biden in new exclusive poll even as views of economy brightenWhat did Biden say about Hur’s report?
Hur’s portrayal of Biden as elderly man with “diminished capacities” quickly became a political liability for Biden because it handed his critics fresh evidence to suggest he isn’t up to serving a second term.
Biden is gearing up for a brutal rematch with former President Donald Trump in November, and multiple polls show Biden’s age is a major concern for many voters.
Hours after Hur’s report became public on F

Washington: In one of the most shocking revelations in Special Counsel Robert Hur’s probe into President Joe Biden’s handling of classified documents, the 81-year-old leader was described as an old man whose memory was so bad that he was unable to recall the date of his own son’s death.

Hur misrepresented the conversation about Beau Biden’s passing as a senior moment, however, according to the transcript of Hur’s interview with Biden.

However, Biden’s indignant claim that Hur brought up Beau Biden’s passing during their interview is refuted by the transcript. The transcript states that Biden, not Hur, was the one who initially brought up Beau Biden’s passing.

The two-day conversation between the president and the special prosecutor in October of last year was far more nuanced than either side has suggested, according to the transcript, which was made public on Tuesday in advance of Hur’s testimony before the House Judiciary Committee.

About Biden, what was said in the Hur report?

Hur came to the conclusion that Biden handled classified documents strewn all over his Delaware home carelessly in his investigative report, which was made public last month. However, because of his “poor memory,” federal investigators claimed, they decided not to press criminal charges against Biden. “.

Get ready for the polls by examining the presidential candidates’ positions on important issues in our Voter Guide.

Hur concluded that Biden’s memory “was significantly limited,” which would make it difficult for a jury to find him guilty. Hur called the president a “well-meaning elderly man with a poor memory” at another point. “.

Hur’s report stated that Biden was unable to recall significant aspects of his own life.

The report states, “Even after a few years, he was unable to recall when his son Beau passed away.”.

Guide visual How does Trump’s report on classified documents compare to that of Biden?

In actuality, what did Joe Biden say about Beau Biden?

The Hur and Biden interview transcript from October. , 2023, showcases a digression-filled discussion that ultimately touches on the subject of Beau Biden, who passed away from brain cancer in 2015.

At one point, Biden—who at times seemed to be thinking aloud—asked what month Beau Biden passed away, but he quickly launched into a detailed discussion about his close relationship with Beau and his other son, Hunter.

Hur started the conversation by inquiring about Biden’s file locations regarding his work at the Biden Center at the University of Pennsylvania, the Biden Institute at the University of Delaware, and the Cancer Moonshot initiative after he resigned as vice president.

“Is that area, like, 2017, 2018?” inquired Biden.

Hur replied, “Yeah, Sir.”.

“Keep in mind, my son is either dying or has been deployed during this time,” said Biden. I remained open to the possibility of running for office again, even though I am now a Penn student. However, I would run for president if I were to run again. And so, what was going on, though? Oh my God, May 30th was the month that Beau passed away. “.

Lawyer Rachel Cotton of the White House: “2015. “.

Man speaking inaudibly: “2015. “.

Biden: “Did he pass away in 2015?”.

Male speaker who is not identified: “It was May of 2015.”. “.

2015, Biden said. “.

Biden’s personal attorney, Robert Bauer: “Or, I believe that was the year, sir, though I’m not sure about the month.”. “.

Hur’s deputy, Marc Krickbaum: “That’s correct, Mr. President.”. It is –”.

“And what’s happened in the interim is that as — and Trump gets elected in November of 2017?” asked Biden.

Speaker (male, unidentified): “2016. “.

Man speaking inaudibly: “’16. “.

Biden: “2016, the year 2016.”. Okay, no problem. What makes 2017 appear here, then?

White House Counsel Ed Siskel: “January 2017 is when you left office.”. “.

Biden: “Yes, that’s correct. However, January is when Trump is sworn in at that point.

Siskel: “That’s right. “.

Biden continued his speech by going into great detail about his boys, his decision to write a book, and the events surrounding a white nationalist rally in Charlottesville, Virginia. led him to declare for the 2020 presidential election.

Beau passed away in 2017, and this is a personal story for Biden. I know you’re all close to your sons and daughters, but Beau was like my right arm and Hunt was my left. This is how the book came to be called Promise Me, Dad. Even though these guys were a year and a day apart, they could still finish each other’s sentences. Everyone was aware of our closeness. In any case, no one in the world questioned whether or not. “.

Hur once recommended that Biden take a break during their talk.

“No, I’ll just keep going to finish it,” Biden retorted. “.

A rematch: Despite improving opinions of the economy, Trump leads Biden by a narrow margin in a recent exclusive poll.

What was said by Biden regarding Hur’s report?

Hur’s depiction of Biden as an elderly man with “diminished capacities” swiftly turned into a political liability for Biden, giving his detractors new information to raise doubts about his suitability for a second term.

Numerous surveys indicate that a significant number of voters are concerned about Biden’s age as he prepares for a brutal rematch with former President Donald Trump in November.

Shortly after Hur’s report was made available to the public on Feb. 9, in a prime-time speech from the White House, a visibly incensed Biden criticized Hur’s findings. Hur’s claim that he couldn’t recall the year his son passed away particularly infuriated Biden.

Biden exclaimed, “How in the hell dare he raise that?”.

Clenching his teeth, Biden remarked, “I don’t need anybody to remind me when he passed away.”.

On the other hand, the transcript makes it abundantly evident that Biden brought up the subject first, not Hur.

The president was “very emotional” about Hur using the report “to make a patently false claim that the president doesn’t somehow remember when his son died,” according to Ian Sams, a spokesman for the White House counsel’s office. “.

Sams declared following the end of Tuesday’s congressional hearing, “The transcript is now available for every American to see.”. It’s evident that the president can recall the precise day his son passed away. “.

Joey Garrison provided a contribution.

The White House is covered by Michael Collins. Adopt his handle, @mcollinsNEWS, on X, formerly Twitter.

Leave a Reply

scroll to top