The parents of the Michigan school shooter were sentenced

Precise News

8 hr 45 min ago Parents of school shooter sentenced to 10 to 15 years in prison.
Jennifer Crumbley began her statement to the court on Tuesday by expressing her condolences to the victims and their families.
James Crumbley apologized to the victims, something he said he had not been able to do yet.
He said he was not aware his son was planning a school shooting, and he asked the judge, “sentence me in a fair way.”
8 hr 48 min ago Prosecutor says she is disappointed James and Jennifer Crumbley did not express remorse From CNN’s Nicki Brown The lead prosecutor in James and Jennifer Crumbley’s criminal trials said it was “disappointing” that the parents didn’t express remorse.
The prosecutor said she didn’t think that the case would set a precedent for parents of other school shooters.
12 hr 17 min ago James Crumbley apologizes to the families of his son’s victims From CNN’s Antoinette Radford James Crumbley, the father of Michigan school shooter Ethan Crumbley, addressed the courtroom, opening his statement by apologizing to the victims, something he said he had not been able to do yet.
12 hr 26 min ago Jennifer Crumbley says previous statement made in court was misinterpreted From CNN’s Maureen Chowdhury Jennifer Crumbley began her statement to the court by expressing her condolences to the victims and their families.

NEUTRAL

eight hours and forty-five minutes ago.

The school shooter’s parents have been sentenced to 10 to 15 years in prison. This is the courtroom action from today.

from CNN personnel.

A few weeks after being found guilty of manslaughter, the parents of the teenager who killed four students in the Oxford, Michigan school shooting in 2021 received sentences ranging from 10 to 15 years in prison on Tuesday.

Ever since their arrest in a Detroit warehouse a few days after the shooting, James and Jennifer Crumbley, who each faced a maximum sentence of 15 years in prison, have been behind bars for over two years. Despite having separate trials, they were sentenced together in a Oakland County courtroom.

As the country continues to struggle with the epidemic of gunfire on campuses and mass shootings, they are the first parents to be held criminally accountable for a mass school shooting perpetrated by their child.

Everyone said the following in today’s court:.

Before the judge imposed the sentence, a number of relatives of the four students who were killed in the shooting gave moving victim impact statements. Justin Shilling’s mother said that “the ripple effects of both James and Jennifer’s failures to act” to stop their son from carrying out the massacre “have devastated us all.”. The father of Hana St. The Crumbleys, according to Juliana, are still trying to shift the blame, and his daughter’s passing “destroyed a large portion of my very soul.”. ****.

Tuesday’s court appearance opened with Jennifer Crumbley offering the victims’ and their families’ condolences. A prior statement she had made during her trial in February while testifying in her own defense was, she added, “completely misunderstood.”. “I’ve asked myself if I would have done anything differently, and I wouldn’t have,” Jennifer Crumbley previously stated. Before her son’s sentencing, she stated that her response would have “absolutely been different” if she had known he was capable of the crimes committed. “.

James Crumbley expressed regret to the victims, something he claimed he had not yet been able to accomplish. “Sentence me in a fair way,” he asked the judge, adding that he was unaware that his son was preparing a school shooting. ****.

In addition to considering the “devastating impact of their gross negligence that was foreseeable,” Oakland County Prosecutor Karen McDonald urged the judge to sentence the Crumbleys more severely than the guidelines call for. The parent’s attorneys requested in two different pre-sentencing memos that the parents receive sentences of no more than five years in prison.

According to Judge Cheryl Matthews, the ruling ought to serve as a disincentive to attempt to prevent school shootings in the future. Her statement, “These convictions confirm repeated acts or lack of acts that could have halted an oncoming runaway train,” was directed at James and Jennifer Crumbley’s inaction. ****.

ninety-five minutes ago.

Who can be held responsible for a mass shooting is established by the Crumbley case.

The CNN’s Celina Tebor.

James and Jennifer Crumbley’s historic trials and shocking verdicts pushed the boundaries of who can be held accountable for mass shootings.

The prosecution of both parents, along with a rise in other criminal prosecutions and civil lawsuits connected to mass shootings, suggests that lawyers are becoming more and more focused on holding accountable individuals and organizations that did not pull the trigger.

Over the last few years, prosecutors have been gradually broadening the definition of who can be prosecuted for a mass shooting, according to a statement made last month by CNN senior legal analyst Elie Honig, a former federal and state prosecutor.

Although he issued a warning that every case is evaluated on its own merits, he stated that “we’ve seen groundbreaking prosecutions of parents and security personnel,” and he anticipated that trend to continue. ****.

It is still unclear if prosecuting people who are not gun owners will have any impact on the quantity of mass shootings that occur in the US. However, Ekow Yankah, a law professor at the University of Michigan, asserts that it has surely increased the tools available to prosecutors.

It provides prosecutors with a new theory and something to try, he told CNN, giving them something to aim for. “It offers prosecutors a set of options to consider when dealing with a terrible crime, such as a mass shooting that has harmed their community and left them frustrated. “.

Learn about a few other well-known prosecutions of non-shooters that have occurred recently.

8 hours, 48 minutes ago.

The prosecutor expresses disappointment that James and Jennifer Crumbley did not apologize.

from Nicki Brown on CNN.

It was “disappointing,” according to the lead prosecutor in the criminal trials of James and Jennifer Crumbley, that the parents didn’t show regret.

“We don’t deny that they feel bad, and feeling bad is normal. Following the Crumbleys’ sentencing on Tuesday, Oakland County Prosecutor Karen McDonald told reporters, “That’s not what’s important to victims of crime.”. “Remorse, which entails admitting wrongdoing and offering an apology or other form of reconciliation, is what they need and want most, and that didn’t happen. “.

The prosecutor expressed her doubt that the case would serve as a model for parents of future school shooters.

McDonald stated, “There’s a difference between precedent-setting and rare, and this is really a rare set of facts, it really is.”.

She continued, “Most of us are aware that you must take reasonable precautions, at the very least, to shield others from risks you are aware are likely.”.

The victims’ families are aware that her team did the “absolute best” they could, according to her statement.

It’s very difficult, dot. to mention how difficult our jobs are and how difficult it is to watch these parents every day, who wake up in excruciating sorrow and watch this happen every day and still carry on,” she said. I am concentrating on that. “.

11 hours and 59 minutes ago.

Ten to fifteen years in prison were handed down to James and Jennifer Crumbley.

The parents of the adolescent who killed four students in an Oxford, Michigan school shooting in 2021, James and Jennifer Crumbley, were found guilty of manslaughter and given prison sentences of 10 to 15 years on Tuesday.

Credit for 858 days already completed will be granted to them.

It was 11 hours and 54 minutes ago.

The judge considers Crumbleys’ sentence to be deterrent.

by Elise Hammond of CNN.

Jennifer Crumbley and James were sentenced, and the judge presiding over the proceedings stated that the outcome should serve as a deterrent to try and prevent school shootings in the future.

Chance knocked louder and louder, time and time again, and was disregarded, according to Judge Cheryl Matthews. “These two people should have responded, but they certainly didn’t. No one did. “.”.

“Repeated acts or a lack of acts that could have stopped an approaching runaway train are confirmed by these convictions,” she continued.

She pledged not to be “swayed by public opinion” when deciding on a sentence and stated that she is “aware of my job in this situation.”.

In the courtroom, Matthews spoke with the families, assuring them that she could never fully comprehend the suffering they are going through despite saying, “I saw what you saw and I heard what you heard” throughout the trials.

11 hours, 39 minutes ago.

The prosecutor asks the judge to take into account the “devastating impact” of the Crumbleys’ “gross negligence.”.

from Nicki Brown of CNN.

Judge Cheryl Matthews was asked to consider the “devastating impact of their gross negligence that was foreseeable” by Oakland County Prosecutor Karen McDonald, who urged the judge to go beyond the recommended sentence for James and Jennifer Crumbley. “.

“To be clear, regret does not imply that one is experiencing extreme guilt. They certainly do. I don’t deny that they are grieving or that they are feeling bad. According to McDonald, in court on Tuesday, “Those victims aren’t looking for that kind of humility and accountability.”.

She went on, saying to the judge:.

When crafting a sentence, it is imperative that you pay attention and take into account the consequences of that egregious negligence. Therefore, we’re asking you to go above and beyond the guidelines because, in my opinion, all the circumstances under the case law, along with the essential consideration of the impact of these crimes, justify you doing so. The people are pleading with you to think about the terrible consequences of their egregious, predictable negligence. ****.

12 hours, 17 minutes ago.

James Crumbley expresses regret to the families of his son’s victims.

from Antoinette Radford on CNN.

The father of Michigan school shooter Ethan Crumbley, James Crumbley, spoke in court and began by expressing regret to the victims, something he claimed he had not yet been able to accomplish.

I wish to express that I cannot fathom the suffering and agony dot. regarding the experiences and hardships that befall families who have lost a child. Losing a child is the greatest fear any parent can have, and losing a child is unfathomable. “I am truly heartbroken for all those involved,” he uttered.

Crumbley expressed her sincere regret and her shock at learning of the deaths of Madisyn Baldwin, Hana St Juliana, Tate Myre, and Justin Shilling.

Crumbley asked Judge Cheryl Matthews to “sentence me in a fair way,” stating that he was unaware his son was plotting a school shooting. “.”.

Twelve hours and twenty-six minutes ago.

Jennifer Crumbley claims that an earlier court declaration was misunderstood.

Maureen Chowdhury of CNN.

In her opening remarks to the court, Jennifer Crumbley offered her sympathies to the victims and their families.

She said, “I am here today to offer my sincere condolences to the families of Hana, Tate, Madisyn, Justin, and to everyone who was impacted on November 30, 2021.”.

A prior statement Crumbley made while taking the stand was “totally misunderstood,” he said. “.

She’s asked herself if there was anything she would have done differently, and the answer is no, she had said when she stood in her own defense during her trial in February. “.

On Tuesday, Crumbley explained that she understood the question and that she would not have responded differently since she could not have predicted her son’s actions.

“My response would be significantly different if I had the benefit of hindsight and the knowledge I have now,” she remarked.

Crumbley went on to say that her response would have “absolutely been different” if she had known her son was capable of the crimes. ****.

“Forevermore, I shall reside in my own inward prison,” she continued.

12 minutes and 38 seconds ago.

The dad of Hana St. According to Juliana, Crumbleys “choose to blame everyone but themselves.”.

from Nicki Brown of CNN.

At the Crumbleys’ sentencing on Tuesday, the father of a victim of the Oxford High School shooting in 2021 stated that James and Jennifer Crumbley still try to shift the blame.

Steve St. said, “The defendants allowed their son to kill my daughter Hana and three other children by their decisions, their indifference, and their egregious negligence.”. The father of Hana St. is Juliana. In a Tuesday victim impact statement, Juliana said.

They made the decision to remain silent. They decided to disobey the cautionary signals. He continued, “And now that we’ve heard all of the criticisms, they still prefer to place the blame elsewhere but on themselves.

Steve St. Juliana claimed that the loss of his daughter “destroyed a large portion of my very soul.”. ****.

“Her high school and college graduations will never bring back happy memories for me. I will never accompany her on her wedding journey as she embarks on her own family’s journey. He said, “I will always be deprived of the opportunity to embrace her and her future offspring.

As St. Juliana stated that as the defendants’ “defiance” grew throughout the trial, his opinion on the Crumbleys’ sentence changed. He stated, “Hana, Madisyn, Tate, and Justin are the ones who have lost everything—not the defendants,” before asking for the parents to get the harshest punishment imaginable.

Tate Myre’s father, Buck Myre, made an impact statement after Steve St. Juliet. His impact statement was the last one to be delivered.

scroll to top