The bill requires public schools to show the video on fetus development

None

Tennessee could soon become the latest state to require public school students to watch a three-minute computer-generated video on fetal development created by an anti-abortion group.
Under the proposed law, schools must incorporate the video, or an equivalent, into their family life curriculum.
Republican Rep. Gino Bulso, who sponsored the House bill, argued in March the video was medically accurate and approved by a committee of medical professionals and experts.
“Students deserve unbiased, medically accurate sex education that helps them make healthy and safe decisions,” Akbari said.
The video begins with the fertilization and implantation of an egg and proceeds to show the embryonic and fetal development of a fetus.
“Baby Olivia is a medically accurate, animated glimpse of human life in the moment of fertilization.
So, the stage the fetus is in at 11 weeks in the video is actually a depiction of a 13-week old fetus, Grossman says.
This bill comes two years after the state of Tennessee banned abortions at all stages of pregnancy, even in cases of rape and incest.

NEUTRAL

An anti-abortion group’s three-minute computer-generated film on fetal development may soon be shown to public school students in Tennessee, making it the latest state to do so.

The state Senate passed the legislation, commonly known as the “Baby Olivia Act,” in a 21-6 vote Thursday and the bill is now headed to Republican Gov. The desk of Bill Lee.

The proposed law mandates that family life curricula in schools include the video, or an equivalent. This curriculum will use “a high-quality, computer-generated animation or high-definition ultrasound of at least three minutes in duration that shows the development of the brain, heart, sex organs, and other vital organs in early fetal development” to cover subjects like human growth, development, and sexuality. “.

A baby is shown in the animation through various stages of development, and it was made by the anti-abortion group Live Action. However, some experts claim the video is medically incorrect and may have serious repercussions.

Representative for Republicans. The House bill’s sponsor, Gino Bulso, claimed in March that the video was endorsed by a committee of experts and medical professionals and was medically accurate. But Tennessee House Democrats claimed to have evidence from the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists that refutes that claim.

In a statement, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) informed CNN that the “Baby Olivia” video, “like much anti-abortion misinformation, is designed to manipulate the emotions of viewers rather than to share evidence-based, scientific information about embryonic and fetal development.”.

The statements made in this video, which were produced by extremists, are largely ideological and biased, and they do not correspond with scientific reality. The dissemination of false information regarding reproductive health is something that ACOG is vehemently against. “.

Leader of the state’s minority, Sen. According to Raumesh Akbari, the video is not worthy of being included in the curriculum.

According to Akbari, “students deserve objective, medically accurate sex education that supports them in making safe and healthy decisions.”. All those objectives are not met by this legislation. “.

Democrat in the House Rep. According to Aftyn Behn, Bulso’s ideas on education are at odds with the pro-life video, which is “incredibly problematic.”.

Behn said, “To use Representative Bulso’s own words, when you were asked about a contentious piece of legislation you carried a few weeks ago, you said a school is a place where a child goes to learn, not a place where a child goes to be indoctrinated.”.

By a vote of 67 to 23, the House approved HB2435 in March.

A medical expert claims the video ignores the mother and is medically incorrect.

The narrated film makes the claim that it offers a chronological account of the events that occur at each stage of pregnancy. The video shows the implantation and fertilization of an egg, followed by the fetal and embryonic development of a fetus.

Senate Republican Sen. The Senate bill’s sponsor, Janice Bowling, stated on Thursday that she supported Bulso’s legislation.

“Baby Olivia offers an animated, medically accurate look at human life at the time of fertilization. Bowling stated, “This is one of the options teachers may choose in showing this type of information. This scientifically accurate video shows her growth as she moves from one developmental stage to the next in preparation for her continued life outside the womb.

Dr. In contrast, Daniel Grossman, an academic at the University of California, San Francisco who specializes in obstetrics, gynecology, and reproductive sciences, calls attention to several errors in the information provided and expresses concern about the lack of correct medical knowledge. “.

“There is no scientific evidence to support the theory that life begins at fertilization. According to medical science, a pregnancy starts when a fertilized egg implants in the uterine wall, he stated to CNN. Accordingly, the video’s timeline would date the phases of pregnancy two weeks earlier than they actually are, giving the impression that the fetus is more developed than it actually is.

According to Grossman, the video’s depiction of an 11-week-old fetus is actually a 13-week-old fetus.

He went on, “I believe that having biased and false information like this in schools is dangerous because it is being used to form and influence public opinion that ultimately affects the legality of abortion—and potentially IVF, contraception, and other medical care.”.

According to Grossman, the portion of the video where the baby’s heartbeat is discussed is also not totally true. Although the video indicates that the baby’s heartbeat can be heard at three weeks, Grossman claims that the heart does not fully form until nine weeks, even though an ultrasound can reveal the cardiac tube’s rhythmic contractions at five or six weeks.

The video also states that a fetus can survive outside the womb at 20 weeks “with a lot of help.” However, according to Grossman, only 10% of babies born at 22 weeks live long enough to be released from the hospital.

The woman whose body the embryo is developing, her feelings about the pregnancy, and how it might be affecting her health are all but ignored, he continued.

For the video, Live Action, the anti-abortion organization that created it, consulted with a panel of medical professionals, including specialists in fetal and embryonic development, according to Noah Brandt, vice president of communications for the organization. Each doctor, according to the group, approved of this presentation.

The president and creator of Live Action, Lila Rose, expressed her gratitude for the bill’s passing:.

“I am pleased that the Baby Olivia Act was passed by the Tennessee state legislature. This is a significant step in teaching students about the fascinating process of human development in the womb. I hope Governor Lee will quickly sign this legislation into law, establishing a model for other states to follow in giving comprehensive education on human development top priority. “.

Tennessee Democratic Rep. In a recent phone conversation with CNN, Justin Jones claimed that the new laws were an attempt to pervert science and religion by giving students false information that was “medically inaccurate.”.

The fact that they are promoting this in our underfunded schools, when teachers are already under pressure to prohibit books on diversity, critical race theory, or history, is disheartening. On top of that, they plan to introduce propaganda into the classroom that will present an inaccurate picture of the world. “.

Additionally, Jones said that GOP lawmakers rejected an amendment that would have given parents the option to opt their kids out of viewing the film.

Regarding the bill and its likelihood of being signed into law, CNN contacted Lee’s office. The law will take immediate effect, beginning with the 2024–2025 academic year, if it is signed.

Planned Parenthood was contacted by CNN as well for comments.

Two years ago, Tennessee outlawed abortions at any point during a pregnancy, including in cases of rape and incest. This bill follows suit. If a pregnant woman’s life and health are seriously in danger, the prohibition will not be lifted.

scroll to top